Drug & Alcohol Newsletter Issue 6
FTA Audits Well ReceivedThe FTA drug and alcohol testing audit program is well underway. The FTA audits assess the compliance of selected transit systemsí drug and alcohol testing programs with the regulatory requirements set forth in 49 CFR Part 653 and Part 654. Several transit systems have completed the process and for the most part, the audits have been well received.
The Miami Valley Regional Transit Authority (MVRTA) in Dayton, Ohio was among the first systems to be audited. Mr. Al Gray, the program manager, expressed very positive comments about the audit process. "The MVRTA has a very strong commitment to safety. We did our best to implement a drug and alcohol testing program that was compliant with the regulatory requirements; and now with the input from the audit I am even more confident that our program is a good one that will serve the system well."
Similarly, other systems indicated that the audit process was a learning experience for everyone. Even with the best of intentions, systems have had difficulty developing programs that are compliant in all respects. The audits provide a mechanism for helping systems identify areas where their programs require improvement. But just as important, the audits validate those parts of a systemís program that are being done well and are consistent with the regulatory requirements.
The audit process is very comprehensive, covering every aspect of your drug and alcohol testing program. It may seem overwhelming at first, but once completed, you will be aware of very specific corrective actions that are necessary to bring your program into compliance. Mr. Jack Fitch of the Jacksonville Transportation Authority (JTA) indicated that the JTA learned a lot from its audit. Questions that were previously unanswered were answered; requirements that had been misunderstood were clarified; and problem areas were identified and corrected.
Mr. Fitch attributes the success of the JTA audit, in part, to the professional and positive attitude of the audit team members. Mr. Fitch went on to say that he also believed that openness and good communication among audit team members, JTA staff, and subcontractors were key to the success of the audit. "The audit was not adversarial. All those involved [the auditors, transit system staff and subcontractors] realized that we shared the same goal - to develop and maintain a compliant program that meets the unique needs of our transit system. Once we realized this, the process went very smoothly."
For more information about the audit process, see the articles presented on pages 2 and 3 of this Update.
|Page 1, sidebar
Introduction....The Federal Transit Administration (FTA) published its final rules on prohibited drug use (49 CFR Part 653) and the prevention of alcohol misuse (49 CFR Part 654) on February 15, 1994. Shortly thereafter, the FTA published the Implementation Guidelines for Drug and Alcohol Regulations in Mass Transit to provide a comprehensive overview of the regulations. Since the Guidelines were published there have been numerous amendments, interpretations, and clarifications to the Drug and Alcohol testing procedures and program requirements. This publication is being provided to update the Guidelines and inform your transit system of all of these changes. This Update is the sixth in a series.
Ways to Prepare for AuditIf you are selected to be audited, there are three primary things that you can do to prepare and make the process go smoothly. First, you should make every effort to ensure that all relevant personnel are available during the site visit. This will include individuals within your organization as well as vendors, safety-sensitive subcontractors, and their respective vendors.
The vendors will include the collection site, Medical Review Officer, Breath Alcohol Technician, and Substance Abuse Professional. The safety-sensitive contractors that will be included in the audit will be identified in the notification letter that you receive from FTA. If you have not already done so, inform those individuals/agencies of the purpose, nature, and extent of the FTA audit, and request that they be available either in person or by telephone during the time of the on-site visit. Also, impart to them the seriousness of the audit and your need for their complete cooperation. Second, upon receipt of the notification letter from FTA, immediately notify the individuals within your organization and your covered contractors regarding the specific materials that FTA has requested. You will be given two weeks to collect, copy, and submit the materials to FTA. The FTA prefers that you collect all materials from your contractors and submit them along with your materials in the same package. You will be requested to send one copy directly to FTA and two additional copies to the Contractor Audit Team. Third, you will need to make the necessary arrangements to have ready access to all relevant records and documents that are required to be maintained by the rules, including individual test results. Please note that this release of information is required under Section 653.7(c) of the drug rule and Section 654.55(c) of the alcohol rule. If any records or information on the drug and alcohol testing program are stored off-site or maintained by a consortium, the information must be retrieved and available on-site for review by the audit team. Explanations that such records are stored in another city/office are not acceptable. The audit team will also need to obtain documentation from vendors and your safety-sensitive contractors. See page 4 of this Update for additional information on recordkeeping requirements.
MIS Forms UnchangedThe MIS forms used to report the results of the drug and alcohol testing program for calendar year 1997 will be the same as those used to report calendar year 1996 data. The standard forms can be found in the back of each regulation and in Appendix I of the Implementation Guidelines.
When compiling data to be reported, make sure that all information can be easily re-accessed as the FTA auditors will attempt to reconstruct the data presented in the forms from your files during an FTA audit.
1998 Random Rates To Be Announced in DecemberThe 1996 drug and alcohol test results for the transit industry will be available by the end of the calendar year. The information was obtained directly from MIS forms submitted by grantees and their contractors earlier in the year. Based on this information, the 1998 random test rates for alcohol and drugs will be determined. These rates will be published in the Federal Register in December and the next Update, scheduled for publication in January. Please note that the annual random percentage rates established in the drug and alcohol rules are minimum rates. An employer is allowed to exceed those rates.
|Page 2, sidebar
Where To Find?.....
49 CFR Part 653 , Prevention of Prohibited Drug Use in Transit Operations
February 15, 1994
December 2, 1994
August 2, 1995
March 6, 1995
New FTA NPRM PublishedOn September 30, 1997, the FTA published a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) in the Federal Register (pages 51076-51078) soliciting comments regarding a proposed change in the drug and alcohol testing regulations, 49 CFR Parts 653 and 654, respectively. The NPRM proposed that in the rare event the employee cannot participate in the FTA collection process following an accident, the employer may accept the results of a test performed by Federal, State, or local officials (i.e., local law enforcement agencies) having independent authority for the test. Under the proposed change, the law enforcement agency test will be in lieu of the FTA test as long as it was administered in accordance with State or local law, even if such procedures do not follow the procedures specified in 49 CFR Part 40. Comments are due by December 1, 1997. Cite Docket No. FTA-97-2925. Copies of the NPRM can be obtained by calling FTAís Office of Safety and Security at (202) 366-2896.
FTA Audit TimelineThe FTA compliance audit process is designed to be completed in its entirety within 20 weeks after notification of the grantee that an audit is scheduled. The notification will be faxed and delivered overnight to direct recipients. Rural systems and their respective state Departments of Transportation will be notified simultaneously.
Every effort is made to schedule audits to avoid conflicts with other FTA oversight efforts such as triennial reviews, financial management oversight reviews, or state management reviews. The audit is scheduled so as not to be an undue burden, but once the dates are established, they are firm. The notification letter will outline the schedule of the audit as illustrated in the chart presented on this page. The letter will also include an agenda and summary of expectations for the audit.
The on-site visit will be conducted six weeks from the date of the notification letter and will take two to four days to complete. At the conclusion of the on-site visit, the FTA audit team will conduct an exit interview. At that time, the grantee/sub-grantee will be presented with a written report and corresponding computer diskette. The report will be considered final and non-negotiable as it represents a compilation of the facts as presented by the grantee/sub-grantee staff, vendors, contractors, and their respective records. Following the completion of the audit and the exit interview, grantees/sub-grantees and their respective safety-sensitive contractors will have 90 days to resolve any identified deficiencies associated with its drug and alcohol testing program. Responses will be required to be entered on the computer diskettes provided during the exit interview and returned to the Contractor Audit Team with corresponding documentation. No time extensions will be considered.
|Notification of Audit||X|
|Requested Material Sent to FTA
and Audit Team
Prepares for Audit
|Documentation of Corrective Actions Due||X|
|Page 3, sidebar
Where To Find?.....
49 CFR Part 654, Prevention of Alcohol Misuse in Transit Operation
February 15, 1994
May 10, 1995
August 2, 1995
March 6, 1995
The information presented on this page should be used to update Chapters 2 and 9 of the Implementation Guidelines.
Paper Trails are EssentialEach employer's recordkeeping must be exhaustive so as to withstand any challenge and to document policies, procedures, and the integrity of the drug and alcohol testing program. Every component of the program must be documented and a paper trail created that can be followed regarding every test decision made. The following types of paper trails must be provided:
Pre-Employment Drug Tests - A Chain of Custody and Control Form and negative test result must be available for each new hire employee. The documentation should include the written notice to each applicant with appropriate signature acknowledging receipt of notification, date and time of test, test result, and hire date.
Post-Accident Tests - Accompanying each accident or incident report should be documentation regarding the decision to test or not to test. First, documentation should indicate whether or not the circumstances constituted an accident under the regulatory definition. Second, documentation should indicate whether or not the employee (driver, dispatcher, maintenance worker) was completely discounted as a contributing factor. The time of the accident and time of the test should be noted. If the test was delayed beyond two hours from the time of the accident, the reason for the delay must be noted. Chain of Custody and alcohol testing forms must be available for each qualifying accident, along with test results.
Random Testing - Documentation must be available regarding the random selection process including how numbers are assigned, how they are drawn, and how the drug and alcohol manager is notified. The number selections, whether in the form of a computer printout or manual worksheet must be maintained for each draw. Likewise, information should be maintained on when the test was scheduled, when the individual was notified and when the test was conducted. Also, documentation should indicate how it was determined if a test was going to be for drugs and alcohol or drugs only. Chain of Custody and alcohol testing forms must be available, with test results for each test conducted.
Reasonable Suspicion - Documentation regarding the circumstances associated with the reasonable suspicion determination must be maintained. The time of the determination should be noted along with the time of the test. The documentation must include the objective factors observed by the trained supervisor regarding the contemporaneous behavior, speech, appearance, or body odor of the individual, witness statements, and employee response. Chain of Custody and/or alcohol test forms must be maintained for each reasonable suspicion determination as well as test results.
Return-to-Duty and Follow-up Testing - Any return-to-duty tests must have corresponding documentation that the individual was referred to the Substance Abuse Professional (SAP) for assessment, the recommended treatment program was successfully completed, and documentation that the SAP recommended that the individual be allowed to return to work. Likewise, follow-up tests must have corresponding documentation of the SAPís recommendation for frequency and duration of follow-up testing. Chain of Custody and alcohol testing forms for return-to-duty and follow-up tests that coincide with the SAPís recommendations as well as test results must be available.
Document SAP ReferralsThe FTA's drug and alcohol testing regulations are silent on whether an employer should dismiss an employee that has tested positive or whether they should be allowed to return-to-duty after successfully completing a rehabilitation program. This decision is left solely up to the employer. However, in either case, the regulations do require that the individual be referred to a substance abuse professional for an assessment and that they are informed of resources available to resolve problems associated with substance abuse. Consequently, you must maintain documentation on SAP referrals that corresponds to every positive test result (except for pre-employment tests), regardless of whether the employee is dismissed, re-assigned or allowed to return to safety-sensitive duty.
|Page 4, sidebar
Where to Find? .....
49 CFR Part 40, Procedures for Transportation Workplace Drug Testing Programs
February 15, 1994
August 19, 1994
April 19, 1995
April 20, 1995
The information presented on this page should be used to update Chapter 9 of the Implementation Guidelines.
Provide Your Contractors Tools and Technical Assistance to Ensure ComplianceAs the FTA grantee or sub-grantee, you are fully responsible for the compliance of your system with the drug and alcohol testing regulations, including your contractors that perform safety-sensitive job functions. (Note: Section 5311 and rural Section 5309 maintenance contractors are exempt.) Consequently, the FTA audit process includes detailed reviews of the drug and alcohol programs of your covered contractors. In addition, the audit will assess the methodology being used by your system to ensure that all covered contractors are in compliance with the rules. Covered contractors include maintenance contractors performing routine, on-going repair or maintenance work. Contractors that perform less routine activities such as warranty, overhaul, component rebuilding or rehabilitation work are not included. Similarly, contractors that supply newly manufactured or reconditioned equipment are excluded, as are facility construction workers.
You should not assume that your contractors are knowledgeable of the regulatory requirements or that they have compliant policies or programs. It is your responsibility to take the necessary actions to ensure their compliance. You are encouraged to communicate the requirements to your contractors and, if necessary, provide them with tools and technical assistance, such as:
- Copies of regulations, Implementation Guidelines, FTA Drug and Alcohol Regulations Updates, and Random Drug Testing Manual;
- Education/training of drug and alcohol program managers;
- Training of safety-sensitive employees and supervisors;
- Assistance in establishing a scientifically valid random selection process;
- Develop specifications and evaluation criteria for testing service vendors;
- Provide a detailed policy review;
- Assistance in the establishment of recordkeeping procedures: and Preparation of MIS reports.
If your contractor(s) does not have the ability to implement a compliant program, you might wish to include them in your own program (i.e., random selection process, testing services). Under this scenario, the contractor would still be responsible for program administration, but you would have greater control over the technical aspect of their testing program.
You should also conduct on-going oversight of your contractors to ensure that their programs remain in compliance. Oversight functions might include requiring and monitoring periodic (i.e., monthly, quarterly) management reports on their testing programs, including policy modifications, changes in testing vendors, training conducted, and the number, type, and results of tests conducted.
You must take whatever actions are necessary and appropriate to ensure contractor compliance. If contractors are unwilling or unable to come into compliance, you must discontinue the use of this contractor for the provision of safety-sensitive duties, or jeopardize your FTA funding.
|Page 5, sidebar
Where To Find?.....
Part 40 Amendments, Con't.
July 16, 1996
July 17, 1996
July 19, 1996
Conforming Products List
Evidential Breath Testing (EBT) Devices
Note: This list will be updated periodically.
Non-evidential Testing Devices
Note: This list will be updated periodically.
The information presented on this page should be used to update Chapters 2, 5, and 9 of the Implementation Guidelines.
Urine Specimen Collection Procedures Guideline Drug Testing Procedures Handbook, Employers Guide to 49 CFR Part 40 Substance Abuse Professional Procedures Guidelines for Transportation Workplace Drug and Alcohol
Testing Programs Medical Review Officer Guide for Regulated Transportation Industries USDOT, Office of Drug Enforcement and Program Compliance, (202) 366-3784
Bulletin Board Service FTA, Office of Safety & Security, (800) 231-2061
FTA World Wide Web home page:
Note: You may experience difficulty trying to reach the FTA's web site.
Drug and Alcohol Consortia Manual
Drug and Alcohol Testing Results; 1995 Annual Report
Random Drug Testing Manual
Substance Abuse in the Transit Industry
Employee Assistance Program for Transit Systems
FTA, Office of Safety and Security, (202) 366-2896
USDOT Drug and Alcohol documents FAX on Demand 1 (800) 225-3784
Produced by: FTA - Office of Safety and Security
400 7th Street SW
Washington, DC 20590
USDOT-John A. Volpe National Transportation Systems Center
Cambridge, MA 02142
RLS & Associates, Inc.
3131 South Dixie Highway, Suite 202
Dayton, OH 45439
Illustrated by: Dan Muko
This document was produced by the FTA Office of Safety and Security. If you have questions or comments regarding this information, please contact that office at 202-366-2896.
You may also contact Pam Hughley, Technical Assistance and Compliance Manager, Public Transportation Office, Washington State Department of Transportation, 360-705-7913 or firstname.lastname@example.org